SPORTbible has previously used the same experiment to compare Barcelona captain Lionel Messi with Argentine icon Diego Maradona. He has been captain of Liverpool since 2003, and has guided them to an FA Cup, a League Cup and a Champions League since then. To be more specific, they will be compared based on their in-game statistics, technical ability, leadership and influence, individual awards and team-based awards. Have we given fans some key stats to debate? He doesn't really get involved physically with people and scores the odd goal here and there. Result: Scholes on 13 points and Gerrard on 16 points. "It's probably more towards Toni Kroos, as a passer and more of a controlling player. Im a casual football player and hardcore fan. Players and managers praise Trent Alexander-Arnold, Steven Gerrard's insane pass vs Arsenal in 2002, Thread names Mo Salah Premier League's best attacker. Likewise, Gerrard was quite well rounded in all aspects, and was probably the more defensive of the three. Both games ended up being 3-3, with Liverpool winning on both on penalties in both occasions, and Gerrard scoring vey important goals in both matches. Not on the pl when football started of course 80s Robson was incredible.". The fallout continued even after Scholes' international retirement in 2004, with Gerrard and Lampard failing to work together in a midfielder two for the Three Lions. Both Lampard and Scholes have been appointed as captains for Chelsea and United, in the past. Incredible. However, back in November, we looked at the response from 19 different footballers (current and former) who answered the Scholes vs Gerrard vs Lampard debate. Answer: Steven Gerrard Admittedly, there's no universally-agreed way to decide which accolades should count here, but Gerrard takes the win by our calculations with at least 50 individual. Something went wrong, please try again later. Can't decide between sheffield university and Warwick Unviersity??? The three former midfielders have been retired for several years but are still often compared by football fans today. So, now that thats out of the way and were all on the same page, lets get into the comparison. There are a host of debates in football which will probably never . Author () - 4. Bonus fun fact, Scholes has received 5 ballon dor nominations throughout his career, but hes surprisingly never received a single vote. Pep Guardiola is pretty well placed to answer the Paul Scholes vs Steven Gerrard vs Frank Lampard debate. These cookies do not store any personal information. Paul Scholes Manchester United Midfielder, Profile & Stats - Premier League It also makes a mockery of claims that Scholes was, in fact, overrated. While all three players played for highly successful teams. Toni Kroos believes Paul Scholes was a superior midfielder than Steven Gerrard and Frank Lampard as he handed down his verdict on one of football's hotly debated topics. Seeing as these players were all midfielders and were given several tasks and responsibilities, I wanted to leave no stone unturned and be as objective as possible. This criterion included chances created, key passes, assists, pass completion, goals, dribbles competed, tackles won, distance covered and many more. Instead, he was deployed in several different positions before he was eventually recognized as a being more effective in the middle of the park. Asked whether there were any current or former players he wishes he could have played with, the Arsenal legend responded with his answer almost immediately. I think Stevie G comes really close to him but Paul Scholes would have to win., After Carragher gave him some stick for picking Scholes over his mate Gerrard, Henry held his hands up and said: Im just saying! He is also one of two midfielders to feature in the top 20 goal scorers of all time in the competition. Therefore, this answer will contain a tad bit of subjectivity. Career Comparison. In fact, we think it's so entertaining that we've decided to help the cause by doing an FAQ run-through of the debate to get the conversation fired up again through lockdown. I was just about to say, the next one right behind - very close - would have been Stevie G, Henry explained. The Liverpool legend received 220 votes throughout his career, with the Chelsea hero recording 169 votes while the United icon failed to pick up a single vote during his storied playing days. Between the mid 90s to roughly the early 2010s, England was blessed with a vast array of incredibly talented football players in virtually every position. He is currently the 5th highest goal scorer in Premier League history, with 177 goals in total. View the player profile of Manchester United Midfielder Paul Scholes, including statistics and photos, on the official website of the Premier League. Once Guardiola had clarified that Ferdinand was asking who he thought was best, the City coach instantly responded: "All respect to Frank [Lampard], to Steven [Gerrard] but Paul Scholes is my favourite one. Gerrard vs Lampard vs Scholes: Answering 14 of the debate - GiveMeSport Biggest capitulation in modern day sports? In essence, this debate will always be open to interpretation. During an appearance on Sky Sports' Monday Night Football in 2019, however, Henry caused a stir on social media with his opinion on the Scholes vs Gerrard debate. ", Others made the case for Scholes, despite Keane's team selection. Date ( ) - 9 2006 .6. Regardless of what the statistics might say or how the discourse on Twitter might unfold, the ballers who know, know. "I love it. As always you can unsubscribe at any time. Each player is awarded one point if they win a particular stat category, while a tie awards each footballer a 0.5 score. His ability to never lose the ball, dribble out of tight spaces, recycle possession, find players from deep and also contribute defensively and offensively was second to none, in my opinion. Sven-Goran Eriksson struggled to fit Frank Lampard, Steven Gerrard and Paul Scholes into the team together, Keane played alongside Paul Scholes for many years at Old Trafford. Meanwhile, another stat-by-stat battle compared United legend Nemanja Vidic against Liverpool star Virgil van Dijk. Scholes vs Lampard vs Gerrard will forever be a matter of which player you preferred to watch, but we like to think our little FAQ session has brought you closer to a definitive answer to an unanswerable question. Subsequently, all three were understandably also moved deeper and deeper towards the end of their careers. Comparatively, Lampard and Gerrard played their last season in England at 36 and 35 years of age and both never produced higher than an 85% pass completion rate in any season throughout their entire careers. The ones most relevant to this discussion are goals, assists and appearances. Reply . Scholes' omission prompted some to suggest Keane had settled the age old, Scholes, Gerrard and Lampard debate, with fans taking to social media to voice their opinion. Gerrard not only has the most Ballon d'Or nominates with six, but his total number of votes (220) defeats Lampard's tally of 169 and Scholes famously never received a single vote from five nominations. Adding onto that, he was one of the greatest leaders of all time. Also, subscribe on YouTube to watch selected articles in video form. Paul Scholes vs Steven Gerrard vs Frank Lampard: 19 footballers who As Im sure youve all seen the title of this article by now, youve probably guessed that the players that I am talking about are none other than Paul Scholes, Steven Gerrard and Frank Lampard. Scholes has never won Player of the Year and has only been in the Team of the Year twice - Gerrard has been in it seven times. When we use these stats alone as a basis for comparison, Lampard clearly wins. Lampard in his prime was a true number 8, focusing in large part on offence. Lampard barely has half of that in second place with 14 accolades and Gerrard brings up the rear with nine trophies of which, infamously, the Premier League crown isn't one. On that note, Id be interested in hearing your takes on these players, comment below who you think was the best out of the three and why. It's another win for the Chelsea manager who scored 29 times for the Three Lions in 106 caps, keeping Gerrard and Scholes at arm's length with their totals of 21 and 14 goals respectively. Alas, we will never know how that couldve turned out. Player Duels: Steven Gerrard Vs Frank Lampard - Bleacher Report Gerrard had the ability to not only be a vocal presence on the field, but also to truly lead by example. He joined GiveMeSport in 2013 and has covered countless football matches, interviewed various high-profile figures and written well over 10,000 articles during that time. What does it mean when someone says that you are self-critical? Gerrard, Scholes and . However, seeing as its all we have, and taking into consideration how dominant Lampards numbers are, Im quite comfortable with giving him the win in this category. The Liverpool legend received 220 votes throughout his career, with the Chelsea hero recording 169 votes while the United icon failed to pick up a single vote during his storied playing days.. Imagine if, by some miracle, there was ever a point in time where they all played for the same time and we actually utilized all of their amazing abilities. But none of that really matters does it? The Cambridge College Hurt/Heal Game [part 2], The Russell Group hurt/heal game (Part 5). While these numbers are obviously elite, Scholes was just on another level in this department. After spending 20 years playing for Manchester United, Scholes retired from professional football in 2013, at 38 years of age. So the next time that Scholes is slandered and lambasted in the latest iteration of the debate with Gerrard and Lampard on social media, just remember the expression on Guardiola's face. Paul Scholes vs Steven Gerrard vs Frank Lampard is one of football's most fascinating debates. Therefore, this category has to go to Paul Scholes. Asked whether there were any. Similar to Scholes, Gerrard did not play in the central midfield position from the offset of his career. Finally, they will all be assessed, based on their overall versatility and longevity. License () - CC BY 2.02. We use your sign-up to provide content in the ways you've consented to and improve our understanding of you. Manchester United legend Scholes and Liverpool icon Gerrard have often been debated alongside Frank Lampard over who was the best midfielder out of the trio. Toni Kroos Asked Who Is The Best Out Of Steven Gerrard, Paul Scholes I think he had everything but the other two, come on, Frank and Steven Gerrard changed this Paul Scholes is my favourite.". Yet another generational talent that is widely considered to be the best player in the history of his club. Lampard received no votes, surprisingly enough, while Gerrard came out on top with 10. Cambridge - MPhil Advanced Computer Science - Entry 2021, Official University of the Arts London 2023 Applicants Thread, Official Cambridge Postgraduate Applicants 2023 Thread, Official Oxford 2023 Postgraduate Applicants Thread, A-level English Literature Study Group 2022-2023. "When I watch those two for Real Madrid in those great European Cup-winning teams, they're the two. However, Wayne Rooney scored the best goal he's ever seen live: *that* overhead kick against Manchester City at Old Trafford. People can have their own opinions. We'll openly admitted that the data is hard to come by in this department, but Transfermarkt attributes 23 international assists to Gerrard, which is more than the 12 and 10 put on Lampard and Scholes' names. However, I feel that there has to be a winner in each category. Seeing as all three of these players started their careers in the early to mid-90s, comparing them from a statistical point of view, with the data available, doesnt yield a concrete outcome. Gerrard is the only player in history to score in Champions League, Uefa Cup, FA Cup and League Cup climaxes as well as producing performances in Istanbul and Cardiff that need no introductions. So, heres how this assessment is going to work; Six separate categories will be used to compare each of these three players. Roy Keane doesn't even rate him but you have Manchester United fans saying Scholes was better than Gerrard. Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. EDITORIAL USE ONLY. Steven Gerrard vs Paul Scholes: Thierry Henry gave his opinion Absolutely. What's more, it's not really that close. Who was the Best Midfielder Between Paul Scholes, Steven Gerrard and Frank Lampard? In both cases, Liverpool were trailing the opposition at one point and he was able to act as the driving force for his team and motivate them to win. As previously stated, this is a measure of who was able to adapt better over the course of their career. The main stats we would look for here are dribbles completed, pass completion rate for both long and short passes, interceptions, tackle success rates and ball recoveries. Posted below is a head-to-head comparison of Scholes and Gerrard's stats in FIFA 20. Published Nov 16, 2020. Paul Scholes VS Steven Gerrard. The Scholes, Lampard or Gerrard debate has raged for over 20 years, with fans split not just on who the greatest midfielder of them all was but also which combination of the two performed better for England. Should i change from a all girl school to coed school in mid year 10? In all seriousness, despite the similarities noted in this write-up, I just want to reiterate that each player fulfilled vastly different roles in their clubs, at their respective peaks. "I think if I had to choose between the two I'd be more like Kroos than Modric. . "Scholes was better than Gerrard or Lampard" - Reddit I mean, I knew that Gerrard was quite prolific in terms of awards too, but I must admit that I was surprised at how close their personal trophy hauls are. Paul Scholes and Steven Gerrard have been placed in a head-to-head FIFA 20 stat comparison battle to determine who holds the better overall attributes. Born and bred in Manchester, Paul Scholes is one of the most recognized and celebrated players from Manchester United most successful period in history. Gerrard achieved a lot more as a player, whereas Scholes helped achieved a lot more as a team. Argue with the captain of the treble winners lol. He spent one year at each of these clubs in 2015 and 2016, respectively, before retiring from the game altogether in 2016. Despite the fact that Gerrards highest ranking is 3rd, Lampard wins this round. He transferred to Chelsea in 2001 and went on to spend 13 years at the club. At the end of the day, depending on who you ask, there are several reasons that point towards any one of these players being superior. Sven-Goran Eriksson was unable to fit all three into the same side, often resulting in criticism from supporters when one of them was left out. r/ManchesterUnited . This category only includes cookies that ensures basic functionalities and security features of the website. ", Who was better: Scholes, Lampard or Gerrard? Official: Aston University A100 2023 Entry Applicant and Offer Holder thread, 2023 Oxbridge Anthropology Postgraduate Application. Most Manchester United fans would argue Scholes was better, while Liverpool fans would say the same about Gerrard. And realistically, this argument can go either way. I mean, the guy scored 22 goals and made 14 assists in 2010, as a midfielder. Is Bukayo Saka the face of the Premier League? Lampard was undoubtedly highly technical and hardworking, and definitely edges it from a offensive awareness and positioning perspective. So, you can be sure that when the question is cast into the spotlight that the corresponding comments section will see hundreds of rivals fans trying to defend their own club legend. This means that Lampards time playing for New York City will not be considered. This amplifies his achievements in his incredible career even more. 19 footballers who have attempted to settle the age-old Scholes vs Gerrard vs Lampard debate. Acceleration: Paul Scholes (77) vs Steven Gerrard (84) -- Gerrard, Sprint speed: Paul Scholes (73) vs Steven Gerrard (81) -- Gerrard, Positioning: Paul Scholes (93) vs Steven Gerrard (92) -- Scholes, Finishing: Paul Scholes (85) vs Steven Gerrard (89) -- Gerrard, Shot power: Paul Scholes (95) vs Steven Gerrard (95) -- tied, Long shots: Paul Scholes (98) vs Steven Gerrard (97) -- Scholes, Volleys: Paul Scholes (89) vs Steven Gerrard (86) -- Scholes, Penalties: Paul Scholes (77) vs Steven Gerrard (86) -- Gerrard, Vision: Paul Scholes (96) vs Steven Gerrard (89) -- Scholes, Crossing: Paul Scholes (91) vs Steven Gerrard (90) -- Scholes, Free-kick accuracy: Paul Scholes (76) vs Steven Gerrard (83) -- Gerrard, Short passing: Paul Scholes (95) vs Steven Gerrard (94) -- Scholes, Long passing: Paul Scholes (96) vs Steven Gerrard (96) -- tied, Curve: Paul Scholes (76) vs Steven Gerrard (83) -- Gerrard, Agility: Paul Scholes (70) vs Steven Gerrard (73) -- Gerrard, Balance: Paul Scholes (91) vs Steven Gerrard (71) -- Scholes, Reactions: Paul Scholes (93) vs Steven Gerrard (91) -- Scholes, Ball control: Paul Scholes (90) vs Steven Gerrard (96) -- Gerrard, Dribbling: Paul Scholes (78) vs Steven Gerrard (91) -- Gerrard, Composure: Paul Scholes (93) vs Steven Gerrard (88) -- Scholes, Interceptions: Paul Scholes (83) vs Steven Gerrard (77) -- Scholes, Heading accuracy: Paul Scholes (84) vs Steven Gerrard (88) -- Gerrard, Defence awareness: Paul Scholes (58) vs Steven Gerrard (77) -- Gerrard, Sliding tackle: Paul Scholes (43) vs Steven Gerrard (74) -- Gerrard, Standing tackle: Paul Scholes (62) vs Steven Gerrard (79) -- Gerrard, Jumping: Paul Scholes (86) vs Steven Gerrard (87) -- Gerrard, Stamina: Paul Scholes (96) vs Steven Gerrard (93) -- Scholes, Strength: Paul Scholes (75) vs Steven Gerrard (83) -- Gerrard, Aggression: Paul Scholes (89) vs Steven Gerrard (87) -- Scholes. Paul Scholes (76) vs Steven Gerrard (83) -- Gerrard Comparatively, Lampard and Gerrard played their last season in England at 36 and 35 years of age and both never produced higher than an 85% pass completion rate in any season throughout their entire careers. No disrespect to Liverpool, but Gerrard was never surrounded by the caliber of players that the other two had. Career Comparison. Have we settled the debate today? The Student Room and The Uni Guide are both part of The Student Room Group. And SPORTbible has now decided to use Futhead to do a side-by-side comparison of Scholes and Gerrard's in-game stats in FIFA 20. Thierry Henry answered the Steven Gerrard vs Paul Scholes debate by giving his honest opinion. He eventually left Chelsea in 2014 and subsequently joined Manchester City and then New York City. It's pretty surprising to learn that Scholes and Lampard were only named in the TOTY twice and three times respectively, leaving them well short of Gerrard's staggering record of eight(!?) Please contact your account representative for further details. His overall understanding of the game allowed him to dictate the pace of each match in a way that is still yet to be matched in the Premier League. This means that we may include adverts from us and third parties based on our knowledge of you. Gerrard in his prime was a true box to box midfielder, capable of being at either end of the pitch at a moment notice and contributing greatly wherever he was. Where to watch football in chester other than pubs, Broadcasting talent deserts BBC after they cancel Lineker, New Adventure. A childhood obsession for all things football developed into a career writing about the beautiful game. Scholes' 92-rated 'Prime Icon Moments' card is up against Gerrard's 93-rated Ultimate Team card for this experiment. Every time we were playing them, we needed to find a way to stop him. Yes, we're delving into one of football's age old questions - who's the greatest midfielder between Scholes, Lampard and Gerrard? However, arguably better than the actual content of his answer was the look on Guardiola's face as he revealed his admiration for Scholes, going all giddy as though he was a fanboy in the stands. Something else to consider is that while Lampard and Scholes were both leaders in their own right, they were almost always surrounded by several other world class players and leaders. These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent. The final criteria is understandably more subjective than the other two. Likewise, Gerrards time in Los Angeles will not be considered. In closing, these are all fantastic players and have all contributed greatly to the world of football. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. In a wide-ranging conversation, Ferdinand just couldn't resist putting the age-old question to one of the greatest managers of all time, and his reaction was so good that it's gone viral months after he initially said it. steven gerrard vs paul scholes [individual awards/achievements] 1x uefa club footballer of the year 8x pfa pl team of the year 3x fifa fifpro world xi 3x uefa team of the year 1x uefa cl final man of the match 6x pl player of the month 2x fa england player of the year 1x ballon d'or bronze award 4x liverpool player of the season 4x liverpool top goal scorer 1x uefa euro team of the tournament . No. This site uses cookies to provide you with a great user experience. what is the content of a finance/accounting module? Copyright The Student Room 2023 all rights reserved. We also may change the frequency you receive our emails from us in order to keep you up to date and give you the best relevant information possible. Scholes on the other hand was one of the greatest deep lying midfielders of all time, in his prime. He began his professional playing career with United in 1993. Mudryk to Arsenal 60M 3RD BID Man United sign Weghorst Porro & Thuram to Chelsea DEALSEnzo DEAL (Football Terrace). Ive always been interested in the game and tried to learn as much as I can about how it all works on and off the pitch. Im Tinashe Chipako, the creator and author of the blog posts on footballiconic.com. . Lampard spent most of his career in various midfield positions but was also utilized as a second striker on occasion. All three played football professionally for roughly two decades, so this is essentially an assessment on how effective they were able to remain, despite the natural evolution of the game over time. "He's different to me because he was quicker than me, he can beat a man, but I see certain traits in him, like controlling a game. Unfortunately, as stated on the Premier League website, the majority of these stats were only recorded comprehensively starting from 2006 onwards. Toni Kroos believes Paul Scholes was a superior midfielder than Steven Gerrard and Frank Lampard as he handed down his verdict on one of football's hotly debated topics. All in all, it's about the umpteen-millionth time that an ex-pro has confessed their admiration for Scholes with Guardiola joining the likes of Zinedine Zidane and Xavi to eulogise about him. You can find all of the latestfootballnewsand rumours right here.