hey hey #54, Strawberry, Red with white drip glaze with green cover., Produced from 1955-57 hey hey hey, #50, The Original Pontiac Indian, , Produced from 1954 , I think ? hey hey hey hey hey hey #141, Panda Bear, , Produced in 1978 hey #140, Davy Crockett, Hand decorated., Produced in 1957 #135, Pears on Basket weave, , Produced in 1957 hey #132, Humpty Dumpty, Huxford lists it as #132, Produced around 1956? #156, Corn, "Ear of Corn", Produced 1958-59 #171, Kookie Kettle, , Produced 1960-77 hey #143, Bear and Beehive, Hand decorated, Produced 1983-1987, #5, Bean Pot Shape, 6-pint, open handles, hand decorated., Produced in 1939 #151, Rag Doll, "Raggedy Ann", Produced 1972-75 #50, The Original Pontiac Indian, , Produced from 1954 , I think ? #18, Pear, Basic yellow or aqua., Produced 1952-57 #151, Rag Doll, "Raggedy Ann", Produced 1972-75 #20, Elephant, With split trunk., Produced in 1945 #147, Barrel, "Cookies" sign on front., Produced 1958-68 #157, Fruit in Basket, "Bushel Basket", Produced in 1961 #143, Lollipops, White with hand-painted lollipops., Produced from 1958-60 hey hey hey hey hey hey #133, Pine Cones on Basket weave, , Produced in 1957 #150, Pig, "Winking Pig", Produced 1972 hey #155, Tulip, "Flower Pot Shape", Produced 1958-59 #28, Amberware Finish, Brown jar, yellow "Cookies", Produced in 1961 #148, Covered Wagon, "Cookies Wagon", Produced 1960-61 hey Great! #148, Covered Wagon, "Cookies Wagon", Produced 1960-61 Q: Where can I find a vintage McCoy Cookie Jar? #141, Panda Bear, , Produced in 1978 #159, Grandma, "Granny", Produced 1972-75 hey Although this cookie jar has a lot of red flags, from crazing to obvious wear and tear marks, its still valuable because of its rare coloring. #132, Humpty Dumpty, Huxford lists it as #132, Produced around 1956? hey hey hey #156, Corn, "Ear of Corn", Produced 1958-59 #52, Pineapple, Natural Colors, Produced 1955-57 #207, McCoy Train Engine Cookie Jars, , Produced in 1962-64 Seman & Eggert - Cookie Jars & McCoy Pottery Belhorn Auctions, LLC Hundreds of pieces of McCoy Pottery and cookie jars by McCoy, American Bisque, Brush, Robinson Ransbottom and others. #142, Bear and Barrel, Hand decorated., Produced in 1978. hey hey #53, Pumpkin, Jack-o-Lantern, Produced 1955 #142, Bear and Barrel, Hand decorated., Produced in 1978. #23, Turkey, Hand decorated in white or brown., Produced in 1945 hey hey #159, Grandma, "Granny", Produced 1972-75 In 1929, the series took the world by storm, catching the attention and love of children and adults everywhere. #146, Barrel, "Cookies" sign on front., Produced 1969-72 #157, Pepper, , Produced 1972-80 #158, Gingerbread Boy, "On barrel shape", Produced in 1961 #25, Dutch Girl, round shape., Produced in 1946 hey #28, Amberware Finish, Brown jar, yellow "Cookies", Produced in 1961 hey hey hey hey #171, Kookie Kettle, , Produced 1960-77 hey #143, Lollipops, White with hand-painted lollipops., Produced from 1958-60 #157, Pepper, , Produced 1972-80 #151, Rag Doll, "Raggedy Ann", Produced 1972-75 hey hey #126, Kitten on Basketweave, White cover with pink base., Produced from 1956-59 hey hey #173, Globe, Aqua, Produced 1960-63 hey hey #171, Kookie Kettle, , Produced 1960-77 #150, Pig, "Winking Pig", Produced 1972 hey #152, Barnum's Animals, "Nabisco Wagon", Produced 1972-73 #33, Bunch of Bananas, , Produced 1948-52 #158, Gingerbread Boy, "On barrel shape", Produced in 1961 hey hey hey hey hey #20, Apple, Red with gold leaf., Produced in 1956-57 hey hey #26, Dutch Boy/Dutch Girl, barrel shape., Produced in 1946 hey #144, Jug (Cookie Jug), Two sizes., Produced 1958-70 hey #36, Mother Goose, Hand Decorated., Produced 1948-52 #21, Barrel Shape, Shape like Dutch Boy cookie jar, Produced in 1945 #53, Pumpkin, Jack-o-Lantern, Produced 1955 hey #207, McCoy Train Engine Cookie Jars, , Produced in 1962-64 hey #146, Barrel, "Cookies" sign on front., Produced 1969-72 hey #28, Amberware Finish, Brown jar, yellow "Cookies", Produced in 1961 396 McCoy Kangaroo Cookie Jar Excellent. #50, The Original Pontiac Indian, , Produced from 1954 , I think ? Turtle 6. #143, Bear and Beehive, Hand decorated, Produced 1983-1987, #37, Decorated Honey Bear, On the side of a tree., Produced 1953-55 hey #147, Barrel, "Cookies" sign on front., Produced 1958-68 hey hey hey #31, Hexagon Jar, square handles., Produced in 1947 hey #156, Corn, "Ear of Corn", Produced 1958-59 #145, Cookie Jug, New design, Produced 1971-78 #7, Round Ball Shape, 6-pint, molded handles., Produced from 1939-1944 hey #175, Animal Crackers, , Produced in 1960 hey hey The McCoy mark from 1940 to 1944 included a logo with the USA written underneath, and this era had the exclusive FLORALINE set. #34, Hobby Horse, hand decorated., Produced from 1948-53 #132, Humpty Dumpty, Huxford lists it as #132, Produced around 1956? #140, Davy Crockett, Hand decorated., Produced in 1957 hey hey hey hey hey 8 Popular Types of McCoy Cookie Jars 1. hey hey #154, Early American Milk Can, , Produced 1972-74 hey #28, Wheat on Mother of Pearl Glaze, , Produced in 1961 #127, Lamb on Basketweave, Brown cover with brown base., Produced 1956-57 #28, Amberware Finish, Brown jar, yellow "Cookies", Produced in 1961 hey #12, Concave Shape, hand decorated., Produced in 1942 #144, Jug (Cookie Jug), Two sizes., Produced 1958-70 hey #28, Amberware Finish, Brown jar, yellow "Cookies", Produced in 1961 hey hey #3, Old Milk Can Shape, tall, hand decorated, molded handles, Produced from 1939-1944 hey p4A Item D9683565 . #132, Humpty Dumpty, Huxford lists it as #132, Produced around 1956? hey hey #159, Grandma, "Granny", Produced 1972-75 #151, Cookie House, , Produced 1958-60 hey hey hey hey #153, Wren House, "Two Colors", Produced 1958-60 This is a copy of a McCoy Cookie jar, widely reproduced. #146, Barrel, "Cookies" sign on front., Produced 1969-72 #136, Cookie Cabin, Ivory with brown., Produced 1956-60 #38, Owls, Mr. and Mrs. Owl, Produced 1952-55 hey hey hey #158, Gingerbread Boy, "On barrel shape", Produced in 1961 hey, #150, Pig, "Winking Pig", Produced 1972 #139, Hen on Nest, Brown hen and yellow nest., Produced 1958-59 #140, Davy Crockett, Hand decorated., Produced in 1957 hey #133, Pine Cones on Basket weave, , Produced in 1957 #174, Christmas Tree, Hand decorated., Produced in 1959. hey, #126, Kitten on Basketweave, White cover with pink base., Produced from 1956-59 hey #156, Corn, "Ear of Corn", Produced 1958-59 hey hey #158, Burlap Bag, "Two different covers", Produced 1972-77 Etsy is powered by 100% renewable electricity. #153, W.C. Fields, "Snack Jar", Produced in 1972-1974 hey #28, Wheat on Mother of Pearl Glaze, , Produced in 1961 #156, Corn, "Ear of Corn", Produced 1958-59 #152, Barnum's Animals, "Nabisco Wagon", Produced 1972-73 hey #159, Grandma, "Granny", Produced 1972-75 hey hey Honey Bear Jar 8. #28, Wheat on Mother of Pearl Glaze, , Produced in 1961 #158, Burlap Bag, "Two different covers", Produced 1972-77 #147, Barrel, "Cookies" sign on front., Produced 1958-68 #136, Cookie Cabin, Ivory with brown., Produced 1956-60 hey #146, Barrel, "Cookies" sign on front., Produced 1969-72 With the hundreds of designs and motifs made into Cookie Jars by the McCoy Pottery company, its easy to buy a fake instead of the original. #153, Wren House, "Two Colors", Produced 1958-60 #12, Concave Shape, hand decorated., Produced in 1942 hey hey hey #157, Pepper, , Produced 1972-80 #151, Rag Doll, "Raggedy Ann", Produced 1972-75 #145, Modern, white with red "Cookies", Produced in 1958 #142, Bear and Barrel, Hand decorated., Produced in 1978. hey #172, Chipmunk, , Produced 1960-61 #156, Canister, "Flower Burst", Produced 1972-73 Thanks to the extensive list compiled by McCoy Potterycollectors, new hobbyists can confirm the authenticity of their items. hey hey #157, Fruit in Basket, "Bushel Basket", Produced in 1961 #139, Hen on Nest, Brown hen and yellow nest., Produced 1958-59 #129, Duck on Basketweave, Yellow cover with yellow base, Produced in 1956 #128, Dog on basketweave, Black cover, with black cover., Produced in 1956 and 1957 hey #97, Stage Coach, hand decorated., Produced in 1956 #38, Owls, Mr. and Mrs. Owl, Produced 1952-55 #145, Modern, white with red "Cookies", Produced in 1958 hey hey #173, Globe, Aqua, Produced 1960-63 #56, Two Kittens in a Basket, Made in 1950's, Produced in 1950's 2010 24: McCoy Gleep Cookie Jar - Excellent See Sold Price. hey hey #152, Barnum's Animals, "Nabisco Wagon", Produced 1972-73 #143, Bear and Beehive, Hand decorated, Produced 1983-1987, #145, Cookie Jug, New design, Produced 1971-78 hey hey #175, Animal Crackers, , Produced in 1960 #136, Cookie Cabin, Ivory with brown., Produced 1956-60 hey #145, Cookie Jug, New design, Produced 1971-78 hey #144, Jug (Cookie Jug), Two sizes., Produced 1958-70 hey #133, Pine Cones on Basket weave, , Produced in 1957 #151, Cookie House, , Produced 1958-60 #55, Rooster, Introduced in 1956 with brown blend., Produced in 1956-58 hey hey hey hey #137, Teepee, Hand decorated, Produced 1956-59 #38, Owls, Mr. and Mrs. Owl, Produced 1952-55 #50, The Original Pontiac Indian, , Produced from 1954 , I think ? hey hey #20, Apple, Yellow or aqua., Produced in 1950-64 hey #129, Duck on Basketweave, Yellow cover with yellow base, Produced in 1956 #151, Rag Doll, "Raggedy Ann", Produced 1972-75 hey hey hey #150, Pig, "Winking Pig", Produced 1972 #158, Burlap Bag, "Two different covers", Produced 1972-77 #153, W.C. Fields, "Snack Jar", Produced in 1972-1974 Besides using the physical features for this assessment, logos are also reliable alternatives. #147, Barrel, "Cookies" sign on front., Produced 1958-68 #97, Stage Coach, hand decorated., Produced in 1956 #143, Bear and Beehive, Hand decorated, Produced 1983-1987, #174, Christmas Tree, Hand decorated., Produced in 1959. #135, Pears on Basket weave, , Produced in 1957 #148, Covered Wagon, "Cookies Wagon", Produced 1960-61 hey hey #142, Bear and Barrel, Hand decorated., Produced in 1978. hey hey #148, Bear, "Hamm's Bear", Produced 1972 #151, Rag Doll, "Raggedy Ann", Produced 1972-75 #20, Apple, Red with gold leaf., Produced in 1956-57 hey #34, Hobby Horse, hand decorated., Produced from 1948-53 hey #33, Bunch of Bananas, , Produced 1948-52 #158, Burlap Bag, "Two different covers", Produced 1972-77 hey #55, Rooster, Introduced in 1956 with brown blend., Produced in 1956-58 hey #172, Chipmunk, , Produced 1960-61 hey hey hey hey #133, Pine Cones on Basket weave, , Produced in 1957 hey hey #142, Bear and Barrel, Hand decorated., Produced in 1978. #139, Hen on Nest, Brown hen and yellow nest., Produced 1958-59 hey #18, Penguin, Called this in the catalogues., Produced in 1940-43 #154, Early American Milk Can, , Produced 1972-74 hey hey #150, Pig, "Winking Pig", Produced 1972 #18, Pear, Basic yellow or aqua., Produced 1952-57 #207, McCoy Train Engine Cookie Jars, , Produced in 1962-64 #28, Amberware Finish, Brown jar, yellow "Cookies", Produced in 1961 hey hey #150, Pig, "Winking Pig", Produced 1972 #97, Stage Coach, hand decorated., Produced in 1956   France   |   English (US)   |   (EUR), remembering account, browser, and regional preferences, remembering privacy and security settings, personalized search, content, and recommendations, helping sellers understand their audience, showing relevant, targeted ads on and off Etsy, remember your login, general, and regional preferences, personalize content, search, recommendations, and offers. hey #143, Lollipops, White with hand-painted lollipops., Produced from 1958-60 hey hey hey hey #172, Chipmunk, , Produced 1960-61 #157, Pepper, , Produced 1972-80 hey #147, Barrel, "Cookies" sign on front., Produced 1958-68 hey #143, Bear and Beehive, Hand decorated, Produced 1983-1987, #126, Kitten on Basketweave, White cover with pink base., Produced from 1956-59 hey #20, Apple, Red with gold leaf., Produced in 1956-57 #28, Cylinder, block handles, half circle finial., Produced in 1946-1954 hey #146, Barrel, "Cookies" sign on front., Produced 1969-72 #173, Globe, Aqua, Produced 1960-63 #148, Covered Wagon, "Cookies Wagon", Produced 1960-61 hey hey #50, Indian, First models made for Pontiac Motors, Produced from 1954-56 #50, The Original Pontiac Indian, , Produced from 1954 , I think ? #158, Gingerbread Boy, "On barrel shape", Produced in 1961 #157, Pepper, , Produced 1972-80 hey hey hey #54, Strawberry, Red with white drip glaze with green cover., Produced from 1955-57 hey hey hey #148, Bear, "Hamm's Bear", Produced 1972 hey #171, Kookie Kettle, , Produced 1960-77 hey hey hey hey #127, Lamb on Basketweave, Brown cover with brown base., Produced 1956-57 hey hey hey #156, Canister, "Flower Burst", Produced 1972-73 #23, Turkey, Hand decorated in white or brown., Produced in 1945 hey hey #207, McCoy Train Engine Cookie Jars, , Produced in 1962-64 #174, Christmas Tree, Hand decorated., Produced in 1959. hey hey hey #139, Hen on Nest, Brown hen and yellow nest., Produced 1958-59 hey #31, Hexagon Jar, square handles., Produced in 1947 The following list is comprised of McCoy Cookie Jars dating from the Late 30's to Present day. hey hey #143, Lollipops, White with hand-painted lollipops., Produced from 1958-60 #147, Barrel, "Cookies" sign on front., Produced 1958-68 hey #143, Lollipops, White with hand-painted lollipops., Produced from 1958-60 hey hey #158, Burlap Bag, "Two different covers", Produced 1972-77 hey #25, Dutch Girl, round shape., Produced in 1946 hey #132, Humpty Dumpty, Huxford lists it as #132, Produced around 1956? hey hey hey #141, Panda Bear, , Produced in 1978 hey hey hey hey Its butt is extended and topped with a short tail thats the cover for the cookie jar. #156, Canister, "Flower Burst", Produced 1972-73 hey #142, Bear and Barrel, Hand decorated., Produced in 1978. #151, Rag Doll, "Raggedy Ann", Produced 1972-75 This business lasted for 60 years as McCoy became the leading stoneware and pottery pieces manufacturer. hey #170, Drum, , Produced 1960 #54, Strawberry, Red with white drip glaze with green cover., Produced from 1955-57 #31, Hexagon Jar, square handles., Produced in 1947 #127, Lamb on Basketweave, Brown cover with brown base., Produced 1956-57 hey #135, Pears on Basket weave, , Produced in 1957 #20, Apple, Yellow or aqua., Produced in 1950-64 #152, Barnum's Animals, "Nabisco Wagon", Produced 1972-73 #23, Turkey, Hand decorated in white or brown., Produced in 1945 #7, Round Ball Shape, 6-pint, molded handles., Produced from 1939-1944 #143, Lollipops, White with hand-painted lollipops., Produced from 1958-60 #171, Kookie Kettle, , Produced 1960-77 hey #141, Panda Bear, , Produced in 1978 #143, Lollipops, White with hand-painted lollipops., Produced from 1958-60 hey hey #22, Bear, Cookie in vest., Produced in 1945. #132, Humpty Dumpty, Huxford lists it as #132, Produced around 1956? #150, Pig, "Winking Pig", Produced 1972 hey hey hey hey hey hey hey #170, Drum, , Produced 1960 hey hey hey hey #40, Clown, In barrel., Produced 1953-55 #134, Apples on Basket weave, , Produced in 1957 #153, Wren House, "Two Colors", Produced 1958-60 hey #137, Teepee, Hand decorated, Produced 1956-59 hey #137, Teepee, Hand decorated, Produced 1956-59 #141, Panda Bear, , Produced in 1978 hey hey #38, Owls, Mr. and Mrs. Owl, Produced 1952-55 #155, Tulip, "Flower Pot Shape", Produced 1958-59 hey hey hey hey #145, Modern, white with red "Cookies", Produced in 1958 #22, Bear, Cookie in vest., Produced in 1945. #18, Pear, Basic yellow or aqua., Produced 1952-57 hey #159, Grandma, "Granny", Produced 1972-75 hey #152, Barnum's Animals, "Nabisco Wagon", Produced 1972-73 hey hey hey hey, #16, Cookie Boy, Hand decorated in plain colors, Produced in 1944 Etsy is powered by 100% renewable electricity. #157, Fruit in Basket, "Bushel Basket", Produced in 1961 #151, Rag Doll, "Raggedy Ann", Produced 1972-75 MCM. Live Aboutsays there was another unreleased version with different words saying, Dem Cookies Sho Got Dat Vitamin A. Consequently, that version would be worth more under its rarity. #150, Pig, "Winking Pig", Produced 1972 hey hey hey hey hey #174, Christmas Tree, Hand decorated., Produced in 1959. hey #158, Gingerbread Boy, "On barrel shape", Produced in 1961 Another thing that makes rare McCoy cookie jars collectible is if it has special features. #151, Cookie House, , Produced 1958-60 #8, Mammy with Cauliflowers, hand decorated, basic white., Produced in 1939 hey #153, Wren House, "Two Colors", Produced 1958-60 #147, Barrel, "Cookies" sign on front., Produced 1958-68 hey #153, Wren House, "Two Colors", Produced 1958-60 #157, Fruit in Basket, "Bushel Basket", Produced in 1961 hey #143, Lollipops, White with hand-painted lollipops., Produced from 1958-60 hey hey #139, Hen on Nest, Brown hen and yellow nest., Produced 1958-59 hey hey hey hey hey Measures just under 11" tall, about 8" wide, and about 7" deep front to back. hey hey hey hey hey hey hey hey #145, Cookie Jug, New design, Produced 1971-78 hey hey #174, Christmas Tree, Hand decorated., Produced in 1959. #28, Amberware Finish, Brown jar, yellow "Cookies", Produced in 1961 #127, Lamb on Basketweave, Brown cover with brown base., Produced 1956-57 #141, Panda Bear, , Produced in 1978 hey hey #145, Cookie Jug, New design, Produced 1971-78 hey #158, Burlap Bag, "Two different covers", Produced 1972-77 hey #28, Wheat on Mother of Pearl Glaze, , Produced in 1961 hey hey hey hey The Honey Bear cookie jar is one of the most intricate McCoy designs ever formed. hey hey #28, Amberware Finish, Brown jar, yellow "Cookies", Produced in 1961 hey #151, Cookie House, , Produced 1958-60 #28, Wheat on Mother of Pearl Glaze, , Produced in 1961 #146, Barrel, "Cookies" sign on front., Produced 1969-72 #158, Gingerbread Boy, "On barrel shape", Produced in 1961 #154, Early American Milk Can, , Produced 1972-74 hey hey hey #28, Wheat on Mother of Pearl Glaze, , Produced in 1961 Beagle Dog 5. hey #170, Drum, , Produced 1960